Is having a representative from a large chemical company on the board that controls air pollution policy a bad idea?

Knox County commissioner Mark Harmon compared that scenario to having a “fox in the henhouse” at the commission’s June 22 meeting.

The group approved reappointing four citizens to serve four-year terms on the Knox County Air Pollution Control (APC) Board.

The APC was formed in 1969 to help set air pollution regulations and limits for the city and county.

Among the names approved on the board was Paul Fortunato, plant manager for Rohm and Haas in Knoxville.

The chemical company has a large plant near downtown Knoxville.

“I just wonder where we’re going with this board,” said Harmon, who noted that Rohm and Haas “does not have the best record for pollution.”

But the county’s director of air quality Lynne Liddington disagreed.

“Rohm and Haas is in compliance with all air quality regulations. They’re not considered a big polluter,” she said.

Liddington also pointed out that the second largest polluter in the area is the University of Tennessee, where Harmon is employed.

The board approved the new terms by a 16-3 vote.

Several commissioners also said they believe it’s time for some new faces on the nine-member board.

“There are other people interested in serving,” said commissioner Amy Broyles. “But that’s not to say the current members aren’t doing a good job.”

One member, Lisa Stinton has been serving for 30 years.

Liddington pointed out that the design of the board is set by the federal Clean Air act and includes a physician, a transportation expert and citizens.

The meetings are open to the public and are held at least once a quarter at the Knox County Health Dept.